We're finally replacing the ancient windows in our house (seriously, they're practically antiques at this point, lol). I'm torn between Andersen's traditional wood windows and their Fibrex ones. Anyone have experience with either? Curious about durability, maintenance, and if the wood ones are really worth the extra hassle.
I've had both Andersen wood and Fibrex windows installed in different homes. Honestly, Fibrex is the way to go if you're big on energy efficiency and low maintenance. Wood looks great, no doubt, but even with modern treatments, you'll eventually deal with repainting or refinishing—especially if your climate swings between extremes. Fibrex holds up really well against weather changes and doesn't warp or fade noticeably over time.
Also, from an insulation standpoint, Fibrex tends to outperform traditional wood frames slightly. Not a massive difference, but noticeable enough on heating bills over the years. If you're set on the classic look of wood, maybe consider it for just the front-facing windows or main living areas? That way you get aesthetics without committing to upkeep everywhere else...
- Totally agree on Fibrex being the easier choice—especially if you're lazy about maintenance like me. 😅
- My parents went with wood windows a few years back, and every summer my dad grumbles about repainting them. Looks awesome, but he's definitely regretting the upkeep.
- One thing I'd add: Fibrex windows seem quieter too. Maybe it's just me, but after replacing our old wood frames with Fibrex, street noise dropped noticeably. Could be coincidence, but I'll take it.
- Also, if you're worried about resale value or curb appeal, mixing wood in front and Fibrex elsewhere is actually pretty smart. Wish I'd thought of that before we did ours...
- Bottom line: unless you're super committed to the classic look (and the work that comes with it), Fibrex is probably your best bet.
Has anyone else noticed Fibrex holding up better in extreme weather? We get some pretty harsh winters here, and my neighbor's wood windows always seem to warp a bit after heavy snow or ice storms. Mine (Fibrex) haven't budged yet... knock on wood, haha. Curious if that's just luck or if Fibrex really handles temperature swings better long-term.
We get some pretty harsh winters here, and my neighbor's wood windows always seem to warp a bit after heavy snow or ice storms.
I've installed both types for clients over the years, and Fibrex does seem to handle moisture and temperature swings better. Wood looks great but needs regular upkeep—painting, sealing, etc. Depends if you're okay with that extra maintenance or prefer something more hands-off.
I've had wood windows in my place for about ten years now, and yeah, winters can be pretty rough on them. Every spring, I find myself checking for little cracks or warping—nothing major, but enough to need some sanding and repainting every couple of years. Honestly, I don't mind it too much since I enjoy DIY projects, but it definitely takes up a weekend here and there.
My brother-in-law went with Fibrex windows about five years ago, and he's barely had to touch them since. They seem to hold up really well through the cold snaps and ice storms we've been getting lately. If you're someone who doesn't want to spend time on maintenance or just doesn't enjoy the upkeep part, Fibrex might be the way to go.
Either way, both options are solid—just depends on how much time you want to spend maintaining them versus doing other stuff around the house.